September 9, 2025
North Dakota homeowners face affordable but rising insurance costs shaped by hail, tornadoes, and Red River flooding risks. Here’s how to protect property while managing premiums.
North Dakota homeowners face a complex insurance landscape shaped by extreme weather patterns, rural property considerations, and unique geographic challenges. Understanding these factors can help inform property protection decisions in the Peace Garden State.
North Dakota homeowners pay an average of $1,828 to $2,805 annually for homeowners insurance, depending on coverage levels and provider choice. According to 2024 data, North Dakota's premiums ranked as the 23rd most affordable in the country at 24% below the national average (MoneyGeek, 2024), though residents should be aware of broader regional trends affecting insurance costs.
The Upper Midwest, including North Dakota, has experienced premium increases faster than the national average, with neighboring states seeing dramatic rate hikes due to severe weather events. Wind and hailstorms, common in the Upper Midwest, are second only to hurricanes in the damage they inflict, potentially affecting North Dakota's future rate environment.
North Dakota's position in the Great Plains exposes homes to frequent and severe hailstorms. Recent storms in June 2024 produced devastating winds, hail, and tornadoes, with one tornado near Enderlin killing three people and destroying several homes. While tornadoes can obliterate communities, hailstorms cause damage across much larger areas, making wind and hail protection an important consideration for North Dakota homeowners.
The state's severe weather patterns are intensifying. Meteorological conditions in 2024 showed highly unstable atmospheric conditions with over 3,000 J/kg of Convective Available Potential Energy (CAPE), creating increased tornado risks. These conditions suggest homeowners may benefit from evaluating their wind and hail protection coverage options.
The Red River Valley, encompassing major cities like Fargo and Grand Forks, presents unique flooding challenges. The Red River Valley is particularly prone to flooding due to its flat terrain and northward-flowing river system, with over 20% of flood insurance claims coming from properties outside designated high-risk flood zones.
The Red River is one of the few rivers in the United States to flow directly north into Canada, with the basin flood plain lying in a glacial lakebed that is relatively flat. This geography creates conditions for spring flooding when snow melts in the valley's southern regions while flows are impeded by ice dams to the north, causing water to surge across low-lying farmland and towns.
The 1997 flood remains a stark reminder of the region's vulnerability. The 1997 Red River flood was the most severe since 1826, reaching more than 3 miles inland in Grand Forks and East Grand Forks, with total damages of US$3.5 billion. More recently, the Fargo-Moorhead area came close to losing the flood fight in 2009, leading to a massive diversion project designed to protect 235,000 people and eliminate flood insurance requirements for more than 5,000 households previously paying around $9,000 per year.
North Dakota's harsh winters create additional property risks. Blizzards, ice storms, and extreme cold can cause property damage through burst pipes, roof collapse from snow loads, and ice dam formation. The state's rural areas may face particular challenges, with many homes relying on propane and wood stoves for heating, which insurers evaluate during underwriting.
Many North Dakota homes sit on large lots or agricultural land, which may require specialized coverage approaches. Traditional HO-3 policies may not adequately address rural properties with detached structures like barns, sheds, and equipment storage buildings. Farm and ranch policies or dwelling fire coverage often provide different protection options for these unique property types.
North Star offers farm coverage and boat or RV liability as add-ons, along with coverage for mobile homes, rental homes, and seasonal homes, recognizing the diverse property types common in North Dakota's rural landscape.
Given the flood risks, particularly in the Red River Valley, homeowners may want to consider NFIP flood insurance. The average flood insurance policy in North Dakota costs about $700 to $1,005 annually, with residents in low to moderate risk areas typically paying about $200 less. Homeowners in federally designated high-risk flood areas are required to purchase flood insurance, while those outside official flood plains may also want to evaluate coverage options.
North Dakota homeowners commonly consider these coverage enhancements:
Water Backup/Sump Overflow Protection: Often considered for homes with basements, which are common throughout the state. This coverage addresses sewer backups and sump pump failures during heavy rainfall events.
Ordinance or Law Coverage: May help cover additional costs when rebuilding older homes to current building codes, particularly relevant in North Dakota's older rural communities.
Extended Replacement Cost/Inflation Guard: With rising material and labor costs, this coverage option helps address potential rebuilding cost increases.
Service Line Coverage: May provide protection for older towns with aging underground utility systems that could fail during extreme weather events.
North Dakota operates without a FAIR Plan, meaning high-risk properties must seek coverage through surplus or specialty carriers. Insurance companies are required to provide adequate notice for cancellation or non-renewal, and insurance scores are commonly used in underwriting.
Credit-based insurance scores significantly impact premiums, with poor credit resulting in average annual premiums of $4,460 compared to lower rates for those with good credit (NerdWallet, 2024). This 59% difference highlights the importance of credit history in insurance pricing.
Navigating North Dakota's complex insurance landscape may benefit from professional guidance. For homeowners seeking to evaluate comprehensive protection options while managing costs, partnering with Covered may provide support in understanding North Dakota's unique risks and evaluating coverage combinations to address severe weather, flooding, and rural property exposures. This approach can help customers feel supported throughout the coverage evaluation process, potentially reducing the complexity of insurance decisions.
Covered is a licensed insurance brokerage. Content partnerships may include promotional considerations. Learn more at itscovered.com/disclosures.
Understanding how North Dakota's rates compare to neighboring states provides context for homeowners:
South Dakota has seen premiums increase 41% over seven years, while Minnesota and Montana have also experienced faster-than-average rate increases. North Dakota's current position may change as insurers evaluate exposure to Upper Midwest severe storms.
Despite rising regional rates, North Dakota homeowners can explore several strategies to manage insurance costs:
Shop Multiple Carriers: Rate differences between companies can be substantial, potentially offering savings opportunities of around $128 per month depending on individual circumstances.
Consider Higher Deductibles: Accepting higher out-of-pocket costs for claims may reduce annual premiums.
Bundle Policies: Combining home and auto insurance often provides discount opportunities.
Maintain Good Credit: Given the significant impact on rates, protecting credit scores may help with affordable coverage.
Implement Risk Reduction: Installing hail-resistant roofing, upgrading heating systems, and maintaining proper drainage may qualify for discounts and reduce claim likelihood.
North Dakota's insurance market faces pressure from climate-related risks and regional trends toward higher premiums. Neighboring Minnesota projects 15% rate increases through 2025, suggesting North Dakota may face similar market pressures.
Proactive homeowners may benefit from comprehensive risk assessment, regular coverage evaluation, and periodic policy reviews to help ensure appropriate protection as the market evolves. Understanding the state's unique challenges from Red River flooding to severe hailstorms can inform decisions that address both property protection and financial considerations.
For homeowners in North Dakota, the goal is balancing comprehensive protection against the state's diverse risks with cost management strategies. Working with knowledgeable insurance professionals and maintaining appropriate coverage levels may be valuable as the regional insurance landscape continues to evolve in response to increasing severe weather frequency and intensity.
This article provides general information about North Dakota’s homeowners insurance market based on available industry data as of 2025. Individual circumstances vary significantly, and premium quotes, coverage options, and policy terms differ by insurance company. Consumers should consult with licensed insurance professionals for specific coverage recommendations and current pricing. Information presented should not be considered as guaranteed outcomes or personalized insurance advice.
Hours of Operation
7 AM to 8 PM CDT
Closed
Closed
Call Us
833-487-2683
*Savings claim based upon averaging actual anonymized savings data for dwelling-only insurance rates paid (from July 2023 - June 2024) by customers of two of Covered’s largest mortgage industry partners across twenty-seven (27) US states. Bundles and non-dwelling insurance coverages were excluded.
† Net Promoter Score (“NPS”)® calculation averages post-purchase customer satisfaction surveys from 9/24/2024 - 2/28/2025. NPS® is a market research metric measuring customer satisfaction with a scoring calculation that incorporates both detractor and promoter customer feedback.
Quotes are presented solely for your convenience. Savings may vary. Rates are subject to change based upon the specific coverage you select and other factors that apply to your situation. CA License #0M81402, doing business as Cubbard Insurance Solutions in California.
